The Best Convertible Car Seat

The best convertible car seat is going to make life as a new parent a whole lot easier, not only giving your child a safe and comfortable platform to ride in the car with you, but also protecting your child in ways that traditional “one-piece” car seats never could.

Finding the right convertible car seat can be a little bit of an uphill battle, not because there are so few top options but because there are so many. Below we highlight the best of the best that you’ll have to pick and choose from!

best convertible car seat
Pros
Cons
Bottom Line
Overall Score
Pros : Just about universally hailed as THE convertible car seat tomorrow. Fantastic side impact crash testing results. More safety awards than almost anything else on the market. Easy installation process.
Cons : A little bit on the heavier side of things and not quite as feature-rich. Not quite as feature-rich as other convertible car seats.
Bottom Line : When safety and security is of the utmost importance (which it should be with any car seat), you just cannot beat this option.
Overall Score :
Safety - 10
Convenience - 10
Installation - 10
Portability - 9.6
Pros : Ranking just below the Britax in crash testing. Weighs in at just 22 pounds. Has a much higher rear facing weight limit than most options. Filled with creature comfort features.
Cons : Installation is a real pain the first time you set it up. Converting this car seat can be a pain, too.
Bottom Line : The next best car seat on the market right now, this is a lightweight, relatively affordable, and convenient system that is a bit of a nightmare to install the first time you pop it out of the box.
Overall Score :
Safety - 9.8
Convenience - 9.5
Installation - 7.0
Portability - 9.8
Pros : Works with standard LATCH configurations in most modern vehicles. Feature-rich, with storage and cupholders. Built-in alarm to let you know when your child is out of safe position.
Cons : Doesn’t rank quite as well on side impact safety ratings. Almost too lightweight.
Bottom Line : Not a bad car seat by any stretch of the imagination, this is a quality, affordable, and dependable system that feels really cheap but is stronger than you’d expect or anticipate.
Overall Score :
Safety - 9.4
Convenience - 9.5
Installation - 9.1
Portability - 9.0
Pros : Strong and durable. Great side impact protection. Relatively lightweight. Works with the LATCH system. Includes extra storage space.
Cons : Not quite as available as other options. Has a stiffer price tag than more feature-rich contenders.
Bottom Line : One of the safest car seats money can buy, you’ll get a pretty fantastic blend of performance and comfort when you snap up this car seat. Demand has led to a limited supply, however, so expect to spend a little bit more for this car seat.
Overall Score :
Safety - 9.6
Convenience - 9.5
Installation - 9.4
Portability - 9.6
Pros : Perfect for newborns and infants. Effortless installation process with Super Cinch straps. Egg shaped seat is comfortable and secure.
Cons : A little bit pricier than most. Not ideal for toddlers or older children.
Bottom Line : This just might be the very best car seat on the market for newborns and infants, but it isn’t going to be very long until your children threaten to outgrow this world-class car seat. If you have the money to upgrade later, this is a great option for new parents.
Overall Score :
Safety - 9.8
Convenience - 9.4
Installation - 9.3
Portability - 9.4

Shopping Guide for the Best Convertible Car Seats

The best convertible car seat is going to make your life a lot easier, but it’s also going to give you a lot more peace of mind every single time you slide behind the wheel of your vehicle with your child in tow.

Convertible car seats open up a world of flexibility that “one-piece” car seats never could, helping you to save money and to eliminate a lot of the clutter that new parents are inevitably going to attract when they purchase things for their babies.

Finding the right system that offers a perfect blend of safety, security, price, and performance that is also effortless to install can be a real challenge. But looking at the five options we highlight in this quick guide will allow you to shortcut your decision-making process in a hurry while guaranteeing you get a quality car seat for your child as well!

Our Top Convertible Car Seat Reviews

Best Rated Convertible Car Seat of 2019

Why you should buy this:
This convertible car seat is all but unanimously considered to be the best of the best available today. Parents wanting the highest level of protection for their children without any headaches setting up this car seat will be more than pleased.

Who it’s for:
Parents that have a budget that can accommodate one of the more expensive car seats on the marketplace are going to find all the bells and whistles they could ever want in this setup.

Why we picked the Britax Marathon ClickTight:
It would have been a glaring omission to exclude this convertible car seat when talking about the top options on the market today. This system is leaps and bounds above everything else out there.

Britax Marathon ClickTight Convertible Car Seat
  • Did You know?

The proprietary Click Tight locking system helps to add an extra layer of protection to this car seat while at the same time significantly streamlining the initial set up as well as popping this car seat into out of your vehicle

10

Safety

10

Convenience

10

Installation

9.6

Portability

9.9

Editor’s Score

Britax Marathon ClickTight review

Absolutely everything about this car seat, from top to bottom, stands apart from the rest of the pack.

While this company has a variety of different models that range from relatively inexpensive options to premium solutions – with a handful of different individual models in between those extremes – this is the model that is all but universally regarded as the best convertible car seat money can buy.

The Marathon CT system has been designed utilizing the latest version of the LATCH safety seat belt protocol, practically rendering the old school method of blocking car seats into a vehicle obsolete while at the same time offering a lot more stability, a lot more security, and a lot less headache when it comes to setting up your car seat.

About as comfortable as one of these options can get, you’re going to find this unit to be enough of a “shell” to protect your child at all times without ever leaving them feeling claustrophobic or overly confined. Side-impact protection is top-notch, steel reinforced frame elements improve protection even more so, and a 14 point harness keeps your child secure no matter what.

Top Rear Facing Convertible Car Seat

Why you should buy this:
The extendable tray feature that this car seat has makes this option a lot more comfortable for children that are a little bit larger, providing five extra inches of rear-facing leg room they wouldn’t have had otherwise.

Who it’s for:
This car seat is ideally suited for those that want a rear-facing car seat that can quickly convert to a more traditional option without any headache or hassle, all with the top level safety features parents today are expecting.

Why we picked the Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1 Convertible Car Seat:
This is almost as good a car seat as our top pick but at a significant discount, with only a handful of bells and whistles missing from this particular model compared to the industry leader.

Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1 Car Seat
  • Did You know?

The safety technology built into this particular convertible car seat has a 10-year expiration date, guaranteeing that the technology will provide plenty of safety for at least a decade and will be able to utilize LATCH connectors.

9.8

Safety

9.5

Convenience

7.0

Installation

9.8

Portability

9.0

Editor’s Score

Graco Extend2Fit 3-in-1 review

This is a brand name that parents know they can trust, and it is certainly one of the most reputable companies when it comes to car seats and other child care products.

Manufactured out of high quality construction materials and specifically designed for children anywhere between 4 pounds and 50 pounds (when it is in its rear-facing configuration), this model can also be reversed to a forward facing set up so that children between 22 pounds and 65 pounds can sit comfortably in the seat.

A proprietary latch system works with the LATCH system found in all modern vehicles, offering a variety of different anchor points that wouldn’t have been available otherwise. This makes the installation of this car seat into practically any vehicle about as easy as it gets.

Premium comfort features are built right into this car seat but never get in the way of safety, making sure that your child is kept protected while enjoying their car rides, too.

Best Affordable Convertible Car Seat

Why you should buy this:
This convertible car seat takes the traditional LATCH system found it all modern vehicles to the next level, offering multiple anchor points that allow for the highest possible level of security you’ll find in car seats today

Who it’s for:
This convertible car seat is very much been designed for parents on the go, with extra storage features, cupholders, and other “creature comforts” built right into the actual system itself. Top-notch across the board.

Why we picked the Evenflo Tribute LX Convertible Car Seat:
Even though you are getting all kinds of bells and whistles with this particular convertible car seat security and safety is still a priority. On top of that, you get a lot of extras with this car seat that you don’t get at this relatively inexpensive price point with other models.

Evenflo Tribute LX Convertible Car Seat
  • Did You know?

The integrated child alarm system lets you know if your child ever gets out of the “safety position”, allowing you to make the necessary course correction so that your child is protected at all times.

9.4

Safety

9.5

Convenience

9.1

Installation

9.0

Portability

9.3

Editor’s Score

Evenflo Tribute LX review

There’s a lot to fall in love with when it comes to this particular car seat, even if it isn’t quite as feature-rich or quite as premium as some of the other options you can find on the market right now.

The overall comfort level of this particular set up has been rated as one of the highest in the industry, but the comfort features never get in the way of the overall security your child is going to enjoy when they are strapped in. Although this unit does have a somewhat lower side impact safety rating, it still is one of the top performers in the industry and is light years ahead of other units that are available at similar price points.

Another big plus for this particular system is the fact that it can be effortlessly installed in most vehicles. It is ultralightweight, some would argue almost too lightweight, but that’s not going to cross your mind when you have a child in one arm, a baby bag in another and are trying to get everything situated in the vehicle all on your own.

Top Rated Safest Convertible Car Seat

Why you should buy this:
One of the top performing side impact convertible car seats you’ll find, safety features are paramount with this particular convertible car seat that works with all modern LATCH systems.

Who it’s for:
If you want to be sure that you are getting one of the safest convertible car seats on the market, and aren’t afraid of paying a premium to do so, this is the kind of car seat you are going to want to get your hands on.

Why we picked the Graco SlimFit All-in-One:
About as safe and secure a convertible car seat as you’ll find today, this is a little bit more of a bare-bones option but when your child’s safety is paramount it doesn’t get better than this.

Graco SlimFit All-in-One Convertible Car Seat
  • Did You know?

This particular model can be a little bit difficult to track down on the market right now because it is in such high demand. Expect prices – even secondary prices – to be high.

9.6

Safety

9.5

Convenience

9.4

Installation

9.6

Portability

9.5

Editor’s Score

Graco SlimFit All-in-One review

This is easily one of the safest car seats available anywhere, and not just one of the safest convertible car seats – but one of the safest car seats of any format.

While the overall safety and security features are absolutely at the top of the list with this particular model, that doesn’t mean that they cut corners or skimped on comfort level, either. The seat utilizes advanced bone and synthetic materials to provide a soft, cushioned, and protective seating platform with a material that is easy to clean, practically waterproof, and isn’t going to cause your child to overheat, either.

As we mentioned earlier, this is one of the most in-demand car seats you’re going to find. Expect to pay a premium because of that, even if you go to the secondary market. This isn’t the kind of car seat you’re going to find overflowing shelves or always in stock online, that’s for sure. But it is well worth tracking one down.\

Top Compact Convertible Car Seat

Why you should buy this:
If you want to guarantee that you never have to fight or fiddle with your convertible car seat when you are installing it in a vehicle, even if you have your hands otherwise full, this is easily the car seat for you.

Who it’s for:
While this car seat can effortlessly accommodate children of all shapes and sizes (within the limits of the seat) it is really best suited for parents of infants and younger children more than anything else.

Why we picked the Chicco NextFit Convertible Car Seat:
When your children are extremely young you want to be sure that they are super safe, protected, and secure in their car seat – not only in the event of an accident but even just driving around. This car seat locks them in.

Chicco NextFit Convertible Car Seat
  • Did You know?

This is definitely a car seat that has been designed with younger children in mind, so if you’re going to invest in this car seat technology it’s not a bad idea to expect having to purchase another car seat later on in your child’s life.

9.8

Safety

9.4

Convenience

9.3

Installation

9.4

Portability

9.4

Editor’s Score

Chicco NextFit Convertible Car Seat review

This was a little bit of a challenge to review, because it is such a fantastic car seat for young children but really lacks some of the creature comforts that older children are going to expect – and that older children will complain about if they get stuck in a seat that doesn’t have those options.

Safety features are definitely the highlight with this particular model, and the “egg shape” that this unit enjoys allows it to provide extra protection – particularly side impact protection – compared to more traditional options. This also allows for a simplified and straightforward installation process and you’ll find that getting your children into and out of this car seat is about as easy as it gets, too.

At the end of the day, this unit can be a little bit pricey if you are going to have to purchase another car seat as your children get older and you look for something a little more feature-rich, something with a little more storage, or something with more bells and whistles.

Of course, because this is such a well-regarded and highly rated car seat you shouldn’t have any trouble whatsoever selling it on the secondary market and putting that money towards a new convertible car seat when you want to make an upgrade.

Last update on 2019-04-19 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Close Menu