The Best Breast Pump

Being a new mom is going to be filled with all kinds of challenges, not the least of which is making sure that your baby is always well fed.

To help make life a little bit easier (and to help you get more sleep), the best breast pump options on the market today – like the ones we highlight below – give you an opportunity to stockpile breast milk so that you or someone else can feed your baby without having to breast-feed every time.

best breast pump
Pros
Cons
Bottom Line
Overall Score
Pros : Double electric pump configuration is powerful but comfortable. Entire setup is lightweight and portable. Two-phase suction system mimics the way babies feed for efficient milk flow. Power cord and battery pack capable.
Cons : A little bit on the pricier side of things. Will require you to clean collection tubes regularly. The motor on this pump is pretty loud.
Bottom Line : At the end of the day, this particular pump is considered by many to be the very best of the best – and we aren’t just talking about new moms out there. Doctors, physicians, and pediatricians recommend this breast pump on a routine basis, and it’s easy to see why.
Overall Score :
Features - 9.7
Ease of Use - 9.8
Pump Power - 9.9
Noise - 9.0
Pros : Offering “hospital strength” capabilities without the bulk. One of the quieter breast pumps on the market today. Digital control scheme is effortless to use. Closed system improves hygiene dramatically. Built-in timer is a dream to use.
Cons : The lack of a battery system makes this a little bit of a chore to use on the go.
Bottom Line : Another of the more highly recommended pumps on the market right now, this system utilizes the same dual suction capabilities as our best reviewed option – though it does lack a power cord. That’s something to consider.
Overall Score :
Features - 9.5
Ease of Use - 9.6
Pump Power - 9.7
Noise - 9.5
Pros : Affordable and convenient to use. Manual pump option means you never need power to use. Small and silent operation offers discrete usage. The ultimate in portable pumping.
Cons : Not quite as comfortable to use as powered pumps. Your hand might get tired if you have to manually pump more than once a day.
Bottom Line : If you don’t need a pump that has all kinds of bells and whistles, but want something a lot more utilitarian, you can’t go wrong with this option. It’s manual operation guarantees you can use it anywhere and everywhere, though you might get tired of pumping all the time unassisted.
Overall Score :
Features - 9.0
Ease of Use - 10
Pump Power - 8.8
Noise - 9.5
Pros : Streamlined and simplified, this is an easy to use pump. Quick and efficient pump rate moves milk into a collection module or bottle without any trouble. Easy to clean and maintain components.
Cons : Not quite as feature-rich as the deluxe pump from this company. Can be a little bit finicky to set up the first time you go to use it. A little bit pricey for what it brings to the table.
Bottom Line : If you don’t have money in your budget for the top-of-the-line Spectra, this model is definitely going to capture your attention. Almost as good as the other Spectra we reviewed, you won’t be disappointed with this unit – though you’ll find it’s a light on special features compared to premium options.
Overall Score :
Features - 8.8
Ease of Use - 9.3
Pump Power - 9.4
Noise - 9.1
Pros : Hospital grade equipment that works right out of the box. Capable of efficient collecting so that you can pump less and rest more. Easy to clean, easy to operate, and easy to stow away when transporting it.
Cons : A little bit heavier and a little bit bulkier than other options. Not quite as feature-rich as some of the other contenders in this review.
Bottom Line : Anytime you’re talking about hospital grade equipment you know you can trust it to produce solid results come in the same is true with this pump. Not exactly the best option on the market today, it is still light years ahead of all but the four other contenders we reviewed.
Overall Score :
Features - 8.1
Ease of Use - 8.7
Pump Power - 9.4
Noise - 9.1

Shopping Guide for the Best Breast Pumps

The right breast pump is going to make your life as a new mom a whole lot easier than it ever would have been without.

Whether you decide to go with a battery-powered/electrical powered option or a manual pump, you’ll find that pumping up a supply of breast milk you can set aside and store is going to invite a lot more help when it comes time to feed your baby.

The ability to rest while someone else feeds nutritious breast milk to your child because you pumped up a steady supply is a game changer, and all of the options we review in this quick guide are going to help you do exactly that!

Our Top Rated Breast Pump Reviews

Best Rated Breast Pump

Why you should buy this:
The double electric pump configuration on this unit makes along pumping times a problem of the past. Lightweight construction materials don’t hinder durability, and the dual phase suction system is top-notch.

  • Dimensions: 13.7 x 5.1 x 10.2 inches
  • Weight: 6.79 pounds
  • Features: Fashable microfiber bag with built-in pump. Battery pack lets you pump anywhere, anytime.

Who it’s for:
This pump is perfect for moms that don’t have a world of time to pump in the first place, you need to have the capabilities of knocking out a pumping session on the go without any hassle.

Why we picked the Medela Pump in Style Advanced:
This is one of the few pumps that has been specifically designed to be able to be used a number of times every day, which means it’s quick and easy to clean and can even be used with a car adapter.

Medela Pump In Style Advanced
  • Did You know?

You get everything you need right out of the box with this pump to get started, including accessories that other options and other brands require you to purchase separately. That helps to keep prices reasonable.

9.7

Features

9.8

Ease of Use

9.9

Pump Power

9.0

Noise

9.6

Editor’s Score

Medela Pump in Style Advanced review

This is certainly one of the more expensive pumps you’ll find on the market today, but at the same time, it is one of the most popular – and for good reason.

Powerful, comfortable, and convenient to use, the fact that new moms are going to be able to use this pump to quickly express milk is a major selling point. Instead of having to sit around for 30 minutes or more to pump only a small amount of milk (and then having to sit around for 30 minutes more later on to do the same), this works to quickly and efficiently express milk in just a few minutes – and capture every single drop to help save time.

On top of that, all of the included accessories really help new moms hit the ground running with this system. Sure, the entire package is a little bit pricier than some of the other options out there, but when you factor in the power, the functionality, and the accessories you get right out of the box it becomes a better value by almost immediately.

Best Portable Breast Pump

Why you should buy this:
This is the kind of pump that works almost silently, helping you to save time by doing double duty as your child sleeps. All new moms know just how important it is to multitask, and this pump is definitely going to help.

  • Dimensions: 7.9 x 7.9 x 6.7 inches
  • Weight: 3.3 pounds
  • Features: BPA/DEHP FREE. Includes a timer and night light

Who it’s for:
Moms that are going to have to pump at work, as well as moms are going to have to pump while their children are asleep, are going to fall in love with this system. Those looking for something that feels a little less mechanical will like this, too.

Why we picked the Spectra Baby USA – S2 Plus Premier:
We selected this particular pump because of the fact that it uses closed system technology to dramatically increase the hygiene of the pump itself, as well as reduce the risk of contamination to the milk your producing.

Spectra Baby USA S2 Plus Premier
  • Did You know?

The engineering that went on behind the scenes to make this pump as silent during operation as possible was nothing short of spectacular, and the results really show. This system is almost whisper quiet.

9.5

Features

9.6

Ease of Use

9.7

Pump Power

9.5

Noise

9.6

Editor’s Score

Spectra Baby USA - S2 Plus Premier Review

A lot of the more popular pumps on the market today are featuring motor technology that runs pretty quietly, but none of them are as whisper silent as this particular unit. Making things all the more impressive is the fact that this pump is able to operate so quietly while still being able to pump both breasts at once, while also having the option to pump a single breast at a time if your child is feeding on the other.

New moms, in particular, are going to appreciate the massage mode of this system that can work to stimulate “letdown mode”. This almost tricks your breasts into thinking that it’s time to start flowing milk again, helping you to cut down on the time you spend nursing while also cutting down the time you spend pumping. It also happens to be pretty restful and relaxing and sure beats having to manually massage yourself all on your own.

Above all else, the fact that this unit offers variable speed and suction system allows new moms to hit that “sweet spot” where everything just kind of comfortable and right.

Best Manual Breast Pump

Why you should buy this:
Unlike a lot of manual pumps, this particular unit is designed with ergonomics in mind and is one of the most comfortable manual pumps money can buy today. Compact, lightweight, and efficient, this set up also interfaces with the electric pumps from this company.

  • Dimensions: 3.5 x 7.7 x 8.9 inches
  • Weight: 14.1 ounces
  • Features: Lightweight and portable. Comes with travel bag. Easy to assemble, use and clean.

Who it’s for:
Not exactly ideally suited for moms that are going to be depending on this pump alone to handle the majority of the heavy lifting for them, this is better as a backup system or as an on the go pump.

Why we picked the Philips Avent Manual Comfort:
For the money, the convenience, and the usability of this particular pump you’d have little to no reason not to get your hands on it, even if it’s only going to be a backup part of your system or something you use on the go or at work.

Philips Avent Manual Comfort
  • Did You know?

It’s impossible to beat the affordability or the ease-of-use that manual pumps bring to the table, but the inclusion of the adapters and the technology that lets you use the same pump with an electric system from Phillips makes it an almost no-brainer kind of investment.

9.0

Features

10

Ease of Use

8.8

Pump Power

9.5

Noise

9.3

Editor’s Score

Philips Avent Manual Comfort review

The only thing you have to do to use this pump right out of the box is given its initial sterilization boil. It’s important that you read the directions for this critical step, but other than that you are ready to rock and roll in just a few minutes – something that cannot be said about most of the other options on the market now.

Of all the different pumps that we have reviewed, this is consistently rated as one of the most comfortable in the bunch. Moms really appreciate the flexible and soft shield, and there are plenty of people writing reviews online that call this a “cloud” or a “cushion” because of how comfortable it really is.

Comfort is obviously a priority with this particular pump, and almost all of the reviews out there speak to the fact that none of the testers experienced any new nipple pain, cracking, or bleeding when they were using this set up exclusively. It doesn’t get much better than that.

Best Electric Breast Pump

Why you should buy this:
Running almost in total silence, you won’t believe just how quick and efficient this closed system is at really helping moms express milk when they get ready for a pump session. It’s tough to beat this performance.

  • Dimensions: 7.9 x 7.9 x 6.7 inches
  • Weight: 3.3 pounds
  • Features: Max suction strength of 250mmHg and the ability to be used as a single or double pump.

Who it’s for:
This is very much for moms that are willing to splash a little bit of extra cash on a double pumping system, as well as those that want complete and total control over the entire experience from start to finish.

Why we picked the Spectra Baby USA – S1 Plus Premier:
The fact that this unit is 100% hospital grade – working to quickly and efficiently extract milk with as little discomfort as humanly possible – really helps to set it apart from the rest of the competition, even if it is pricey.

Spectra Baby USA S1 Plus Premier
  • Did You know?

The system uses 100% rechargeable batteries, giving you better control over how you use into play this pump in the future. Just as soon as the batteries reach a full charge you have 60 minutes of consistent pumping, without any hiccups along the way.

8.8

Features

9.3

Ease of Use

9.4

Pump Power

9.1

Noise

9.2

Editor’s Score

Spectra Baby USA – S1 Plus Premier review

It’s almost unbelievable that a system this powerful, this efficient, and this highly regarded also happens to be extremely portable.

New moms never know exactly where they are going to find themselves, and new families are regularly heading out on adventures that are anything but planned and a lot more impromptu than expected. The fact that you don’t have to worry about whether or not your pump is going to work wherever you might find yourself – or on the way to wherever you are headed – is a major advantage this system has over the rest of the pack.

The inclusion of the rechargeable battery system is another major bonus, particularly since you can invest in a secondary set of batteries to have charged up and ready to go when the old ones need to be swapped out. The included timer is a major quality-of-life upgrade, and you’d be hard-pressed to find any double pumping system that is more comfortable than this one.

Don’t forget about the nightlight, either. It’s a small feature but infinitely useful!

Best Hospital Grade Breast Pump

Why you should buy this:
There isn’t a whole lot of set up necessary to get this particular pump up and running. Combine that with the fact that it is truly a hospital grade solution, with all the bells and whistles that entails, and you have something really special here.

  • Dimensions: 13 x 8 x 10 inches
  • Weight: 6.72 pounds
  • Features: Designed to mimic a baby’s natural nursing rhythm. 2-Phase Expression technology.

Who it’s for:
This particular pumping system is perfect for moms that aren’t willing to compromise. It’s a little bit heavier, a little bit bulkier than some of the other options out there but it definitely gets the job done without any discomfort whatsoever.

Why we picked the Medela Symphony Breast Pump – Hospital Grade:
Dual-phase expression technology is the trademark of this company, and it allows for this system, in particular, to be much more efficient – and a lot faster – and helping new moms express milk without having to spend all kinds of time pumping.

Medela Symphony Breast Pump Hospital Grade
  • Did You know?

Considered safe for everyday use without all kinds of cleaning and maintenance necessary, you’re also going to appreciate the fact that this double pump system can be used in single mode so that moms can choose to pump both or just one breast at a time.

8.1

Features

8.7

Ease of Use

9.4

Pump Power

9.1

Noise

8.8

Editor’s Score

Medela Symphony Breast Pump Review

A lot of new moms get scared off of hospital grade systems just because they seem like they involve a lot more than the more commercially available options, but that’s not the truth with this unit.

Sure, there’s a lot of technology “under the hood” that makes this pumping system possible. But when you get right down to it the only things you are likely to interface with a digital screen, and on/off button, a letdown button, and a control knob that helps you dial in the speed and suction controls of the expression system.

Other than that, this is mostly a “set it and forget it” kind of system which is a little bit bigger and a little bit bulkier than some of the other contenders we have reviewed, but it’s no less effective and no less convenient to use.

Most reviewers are blown away by the suction power and volume this device is capable of, as well as how comfortable it is even when it gets dialed up. It’s tough to find any real faults with this unit aside from its size and its bulk, which is why it comes so highly recommended.

Breast Pump FAQ

How do breast pumps work?

Breast pumps use suction to draw out milk from the breast. There are electric and manual versions to choose from depending on personal preference and what works best for each individual. The suction mimics that of a baby eating and draws the milk from the breast for feeding.

How long do breast pumps last?

When taken care of properly, breast pumps can last for many years. It is important to properly clean and store them between each use in order to get more prolonged used from them. As with anything electronic, there is a chance that there could be issues with the motor but, they often come with a warranty.

What breast pumps are covered by my insurance?

Different insurance carriers cover different types of breast pumps. There is often a website available for consumers to see a list of the covered pumps. If you are unable to find a list, you should contact the customer service department of your insurance agency to get the correct information.

Is it safe to share breast pumps?

It is not recommended to share breast pumps. This can spread germs and cause cross contamination because breast milk is a bodily fluid. It is possible to purchase new hoses and fittings and use just the motor part of the breast pump but, it is never advised to share the plastic parts that the milk travels through.

Do breast pumps hurt?

When choosing a breast pump you want to make sure you get the proper size fittings. Throughout breastfeeding, the nipple area may become sore. However, a pump should not cause any pain to a woman when she uses it. If there is pain, turn off the pump and readjust the fitting to make sure it is securely placed on the nipple.

Does Medicaid pay for breast pumps?

Medicaid in many states has begun covering the cost of breast pumps. The type that are covered and the stipulations vary from state to state. This is something that you would need to contact your Medicaid office about to find out what you need to do to get one covered and what types they will cover.

Can pumping cause cracked nipples?

If the fitting is not situated properly on the nipple area, there can be irritation caused, such as cracked nipples. The use of Lanolin is great in helping to heal cracked nipples. If this is a common occurrence with you, you may want to consider getting a different size fitting for your pump.

Last update on 2019-04-19 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Close Menu